Return to CreateDebate.comlnoon3 • Join this debate community

Mrs N


Debate Info

61
43
I agree with this statement I do not agree
Debate Score:104
Arguments:57
Total Votes:135
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 I agree with this statement (37)
 
 I do not agree (20)

Debate Creator

lnoon3(16) pic



12 year olds should be able to watch M rated movies

Discuss your opinions/facts about this statement. Think about your choice of emotive language and any persuasive techniques you could use to SELL your point of view. Have fun!Cool

I agree with this statement

Side Score: 61
VS.

I do not agree

Side Score: 43
3 points

I think that if the child is mature enough to handle m movies then they should be able to watch them! Although ultimately it's up to the parents desicion what shows the kids are allowed tp watch, but i think that it's safe to say that a lot of 12 year old do watch M movies. People are saying that they shouldn't be able to watch M movies because of the Violence, Language, Sexual references etc. But isn't things like the news sometimes just as bad?? you see murders, suicides etc. on the news all the time. Watching M movies is preparing your child for what they're inevitably going to face in the future.

Side: I agree with this statement
0 points

That is really forceful and totally true rhi, I never thought about the fact that the news is so confronting and many kids watch it because their parents do!!! It is the same as 60 minutes and even some morning shows children may c in process for preparing for school

Side: I agree with this statement
0 points

I've always thought news is just as bad as M movies! M movies are almost a reflection of what is happening on the news. And the news isn't made up but most movies are. Your right that kids will eventually face these problems sometime in their life.

Great argument!

Side: I agree with this statement
0 points

That is so true! Some m rated movies are just as bad as the news, as the news shows you murders that are real and let children be aware that these things are actually happening whereas in movies, tehy have a high understanding that these things are made up.

Side: I agree with this statement
2 points

I Agree if your parents think that your are mature enough to handle M15+ then you can handle sexual,swearing,violence and if they don't think you are mature enough and can't handle movies that involvle those scenes then your parents shouldn't let you view the movie until they think you can handle it.

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

I Agree if your parents think that you should watch M movies if the don't think you should be just deal with it.My mum said it depends on what it is.

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

Yea, your right Bailey. Its also your parents choice, and if they're not ready for us to see whatwe will face in the future then thats their choice.

Side: I agree with this statement
2 points

I believe that it is up to the maturity of the child and the way that the child handles violence, adult themes and violent language. The parents are responsible for their children and that includes the movies that they watch, not the child. Certain M rated movies are worse than others and therefore the child may be allowed to watch some M rated films and not others. However if a child is responsible, mature and sensible then they would feel more comfortable watching higher graphic movies.

Side: I agree with this statement
2 points

Once children reach a stage of maturity (12-15 ish) they can watch M rated movies. Most kids now have mobile phones, MSN and some even have laptops all these item can display what you would find in an M rated movies. Also kids watch Family Guy, Futurama and simpsons these are rated M and parents let thier child watch them......... whats the difference

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

That's true! When these classifications were made, children of our age were A LOT more immature than we are now, and thats just another fact of life, 12 year olds are already watching shows on TV just as bad for them! So why stop now?

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

12 year olds are generally much more mature than we give them credit for. I know of some 12 year olds that are very aware of the dangerous messages that Hollywood portrays in movies these days. BUT, that does not mean that 12 year olds should be sheltered from 'real life' scenarios. It is up to parents to determine if their 12 year old is mature enough, NOT the Film and TV Classification board!

Side: I agree with this statement
3 points

I am with Mrs Noonan! PARENTS can decide if their child can watch M rated movies, knowing what the child can handle and how mature they are; meaning that they may or may not be allowed to watch a particular movie!!

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

12 year olds are generally mature so i think they are old enough to handle M rated movies though it is up to their parents.

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

That is right it should be up to the parents. They know best for us.

Side: Parents should have a say
1 point

I think 12 year olds should be allowed to watch M rated movies if you can tell they are mature enough and they dont muck around about it, and dont repeat some words they say if they are swear words.

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

Yes i agree 12 year old children should be allowed to watch M rated movies but however there are still some children who think it is ok to copy an offensive or violent action the actor has made. Ultimately it is the parents choice on how mature and aware their kids are!

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

I believe 12 year olds should be able to watch movies rated M. Kids at this age should be mature enough to handle the things that happen in the movie. All M movies no matter what they have in them is made to entertain or influence emotion to people watching the movie. It shouldn't be any difference with 12 year olds. Kids know or should know that WHatever is happening they would face someday anyway. I go with the idea that Kids should be able to watch these movies. =] I also believe 12 year olds should because most movies today are being madewith worse and harsher ratings. If you go into a video store and look around the majority of the movies are m or above. Also, most of my favourite movies are M. XD

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

I cannot even believe that this topic is up for debate. The answer is clear: 12 year olds should be allowed to watch M rated movies. So many already do. I mean why shouldn't they? Aren't they mature enough? They are about to go into high school and have everyone expect them to have to do everything by themselves, no parental help. So why can't they watch these harmless movies. And, yes, I know that some people believe that 12 years olds will copy what they see or something like that, but all we need responsibility and this is a perfect example. If we ban 12 year olds from watching M rated movies, it is like saying that we expect them to become mature instantly. They need to take little steps to becoming the mature 20 year old that lives by themself. So, yes it is clear to say that I am STRONGLY AGAINST this view.

You can find this on the OTHER side because i am a freak! Ha Ha HA !!!!!!!!!!

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

That is an excellent point jessl! i agree! People expect us do be mature and have no parental help in the teen years. But then they're saying we don't have the right to watch am M rated movie???

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

I believe that it all depends on the maturity of the child. I picked out 3 movies in my dvd cupboard that were rated M... the Pursuit of Happiness, Charlie's angels and Ghost Whisperer. Now, I know some 8 year olds that have seen these movies and not been given nightmares or copied bad language from them. However, some parents to not agree that their 12 year old children are ready to watch m rated movies as some of them have mild coarse language. All up i think that the majority of 12 year olds should be able to watch m rated movies as the maturity and understanding of them is at a very high level.

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

12 year olds should be able to watch M rated movies because when you get up in the morning we see the news and at night we see the news, current affairs and shows like 20-1 and Two and a half men which contain violence, coarse language, sexual references and some nudity. Is there much difference between the shows we see on TV everyday to the what is on a M rated movie?

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

I think dat kid rule FUCK U ...................................JFGUEFGUE GMVD NEEGFE UFHEFH BEUDGKDGDGKDKKKDGJKDVDL

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

I honestly don't see any 12-year-olds like myself going ahead and copying scenes from a movie. Most of us are much more mature than people think. I know, however, that there are some kids who just aren't as mature. That doesn't mean they will never mature, it just shows variety in humans. Here in the States, movies that would be rated M are rated R, where as long as an adult accompanies them, they can watch. So I think it's based on maturity. If their parent really thinks they would COPY a scene from, say, a fire fight, then go ahead. Don't allow your child to watch. If you think that your child is mentally secure enough to watch a movie like a regular person, please. Let them watch the movie. This debate is raging in all topics, like video games and TV shows. Sometimes even books. But I personally think that most 12-year-olds are mature enough to watch a movie without getting themselves or others hurt.

Side: I agree with this statement
0 points

I believe 12 year olds SHOULD watch M rated movies because we are much more muture at that age and can handle an elderly movie. They should be able to because its amazing to know we can be trusted and able to know adults think of 12 year olds reponsible. Also younger and more childish films to begin to bore 12 year olds and so they should feel that they can watch a older film and not wait around until they are 15 years of age. a2 year olds can be trusted with rated movies because they would not repeat violence and swearing in everyday life, so that is why I think12 year olds SHOULD watch M rated movies!

Tori

Side: I agree with this statement
lukestar146(1) Disputed
1 point

In real life there is some kids that are not emotionally ready for violence.

Side: I do not agree
1 point

That is true! We can handle M movies. M movies dont really state that 15 and under age is prophited from watching them. So kids should feel free in watching M movies. good job!

Side: I agree with this statement
0 points

Thats a good point Torz, - I certainly feel that i get bored during some PG- G movies

Side: I agree with this statement
4 points

I dont think that 12 year olds should be allowed to watch M rated movies because some 12 year olds watch these movies and they think that it is alright to do some of the things that were in that movie. Then they start to act like that character and they do the things that they saw on that movie. People get hurt when kids make the wrong decisions about the movies that they watch.

Other M rated movies include swearing, sexual themes and violence. Swearing should be heard from 12 year old mouths until they are older and more mature.

12 year olds should not be allowed to watch M rated movies.

Side: I do not agree
3 points

Good points made Nic! A well written argument that shows thought.

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

A very good discussion.

I agree that children can not watch M-rated films.

Side: I do not agree
4 points

I think it should be the parents decision, they should be able to decide what their children are exposed to. Mabye parents will want to watch the movie before they let their children watch it just to see if it is appropriate.

Side: Parents should have a say
2 points

I kind of agree Madz but children should be trusted with the luxury of watching M rated movies without theri parents watching it first. But if they abuse this trust then yes your Idea SHOULD come into play. Here Here (Good job)

Side: I do not agree
3 points

12 year olds shouldn't be able to watch M rated movies because most of the movies have violent parts or sexual themes as well as bad language for our age to hear.

We don't need to know those things until we get more mature and don't have these stories/ movies in your head! It can influence us and can act out our life!

If kids watch these movies constantly instead of PG also G movies we can sometimes it is okay to do what he/she said which is not true...

A movie is a movie, not all movies are true stories!!!!

Twelve year olds can watch OTHER movies insteads of M rated!!

Side: I do not agree
rhiannyn(5) Disputed
5 points

But what if the child is mature enough? and understand that this is a movie and it's not alright to be doing the things they do on the movie - and also they're is some M rated moves, that have great messages in them - they aren't all bad!

Side: I agree with this statement
lnoon3(16) Disputed
2 points

There are not many 12 yr olds that are mature to handle the grpahic, sometimes ridiculously obscene content that is often present in M rated films. Some of you say that it is up to parents? I say that I know many parents have NO idea about what is really in some of these movies BEFORE they let their children watch them. Do we allow all 12yr olds (by law) and just hope that paretns and children will be responsible, or do we set a law that DOES protect children regardless?? Tough choice isn't it?

Side: I do not agree
bpitt4(3) Disputed
4 points

I agree with Zoe you can't protect your kids from everything in the world I think parents should let there kids have boundrys and limits and if you cant controll there limits then don't let it happen then.

Side: I agree with this statement
4 points

Exactly and it depends on the parents limitations to watch their children watch see participate in or experience.

Side: I agree with this statement
shk20177(1) Disputed
2 points

I can't understand what you are saying, bpitt4

Also kids can go crazy after they watched m rated movies and copy it.

Side: I do not agree
3 points

I totally support your arguments J - great work! AND ur the first!

Side: I agree with this statement
zcoll6(5) Disputed
3 points

Perhaps they might have violent or sexual themes, but honestly you CAN'T protect your children from everything and if you do then when the time comes that they leave home it will be a culture shock. They WON'T understand things and everything will b scary or new to them this may cause children to reject what their parents did or they might never be able to understand or know what is really out there and at this age they are mature enough to tell themselves if it is too scary or too graphic, rather than their parent's deciding everything for them...

And as you said a movie is a movie not all stories are true!!! Children 12 years of age understand that and won't copy/imitate any behavior they watch knowing it is not true!!!!

Side: I do not agree
1 point

Great arguments Zoe! You really have nailed some great truths in what you say. Good Job!

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

Thats so true! I was caught out when my Mum said u can watch a certain movie but i decided myself it was a bit to graphic.

I see kids that are 8 running around pretending that they were power rangers from movies but when they are older they lose that habit and become more mature. Great Argument!

Side: I agree with this statement
3 points

Are you serious? This cannot possibly be allowed to become law - how ridiculous! !2 year olds still cannot go to bed at night without wondering what 'that' noise was. So let's face it, they are not going to cope with the mature content in M rated films and TV shows. 12 year olds watching M rated... I don't think so.

Side: I do not agree
Jlams1(6) Disputed
1 point

That is not true in all cases Mrs N. We should be trusted to watch M rated movies because it isn't fair for the mature people who can watch them responsibly if they are not. How can we become mature young adults if we aren't even trusted to watch a simple M rated movie? And you wonder why we have 20 year olds still living at home? If we cannot be given a little responsibility at our age how are we going to go when we are released into the big wide world? Do you GET my point?

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

Oooooh! good points Miss JessL! I was hoping someone would argue back. Let's use the example of year 7's at our school - do you seriously believe that all of these kids are mature enough to watch the likes of 'I am Legend' (rated M) where a scientist is surrounded by “The Infected” – victims of the plague who have mutated into carnivorous beings who can only exist in the dark and who will devour or infect anyone or anything in their path! I would imagine this type of movie would cause nightmares for some time with MANY of our 7's!!

Side: I agree with this statement
3 points

That is true Zoe we can't be kept from all of sexual themes as well as language and all the others but it all comes down to maturity!

BUT some M rated movies can pollute your mind!

(sexual themes, language!!!)

That is from my perspective,

Once you've seen it, You keep seeing those kind of things or saying those kind of things!!

Side: I do not agree
zcoll6(5) Disputed
2 points

What you have said is true but if children are allowed to watch the movies they should be able to deferencitate between movies (not true stories) and reality! If they can't do that they are not prepared for the context in which m movies portray. And that comes back on the parents choice whether their children are prepared to watch those movies!!!

Side: I agree with this statement
2 points

I Agree Zoe. It is up to the Kids to know wether or not to use the language or anything else seen in these movies. Here Here

Side: I agree with this statement
2 points

I believe that parents have been through what we are going through and they know what is right for you.

Side: Parents should have a say
2 points

This is Jessl

I cannot even believe that this topic is up for debate. The answer is clear: 12 year olds should be allowed to watch M rated movies. So many already do. I mean why shouldn't they? Aren't they mature enough? They are about to go into high school and have everyone expect them to have to do everything by themselves, no parental help. So why can't they watch these harmless movies. And, yes, I know that some people believe that 12 years olds will copy what they see or something like that, but all we need responsibility and this is a perfect example. If we ban 12 year olds from watching M rated movies, it is like saying that we expect them to become mature instantly. They need to take little steps to becoming the mature 20 year old that lives by themself. So, yes it is clear to say that I am STRONGLY AGAINST this view.

I am changing my account FYI

Side: I do not agree
2 points

I cannot even believe that this topic is up for debate. The answer is clear: 12 year olds should be allowed to watch M rated movies. So many already do. I mean why shouldn't they? Aren't they mature enough? They are about to go into high school and have everyone expect them to have to do everything by themselves, no parental help. So why can't they watch these harmless movies. And, yes, I know that some people believe that 12 years olds will copy what they see or something like that, but all we need responsibility and this is a perfect example. If we ban 12 year olds from watching M rated movies, it is like saying that we expect them to become mature instantly. They need to take little steps to becoming the mature 20 year old that lives by themself. So, yes it is clear to say that I am STRONGLY AGAINST this view.

I Re-wrote it incase

Side: I do not agree
shk20177(1) Disputed
1 point

You wrote this argument in the wrong place.

Anyway what if they get crazy about M-rated movies and copy them?

Side: I do not agree
shk20177(1) Disputed
1 point

You wrote this argument in the wrong place.

Anyway what if they get crazy about M-rated movies and copy them?

Side: I do not agree
2 points

OPPS sorry i didnt read that this was the agree with having 12 yeasr NOT watch M Rated Movies!!!!!!!!! GEZZZZ. I feel sooooooo embaressed now!!!!!!!!!

Side: I do not agree
lmcar4(6) Disputed
2 points

He he he, I almost did that too! There MIGHT be a way of deleting your arguement...

Side: I agree with this statement
1 point

I think that 12 year olds should not watch M rated movies because they can copy the things shown in the scenes.

Side: I do not agree
1 point

I think that 12 year olds should not watch M rated movies because they can copy the things shown in the scenes.

Side: I do not agree